The Fireplace

Experience authentic Italian cuisine at The Fireplace American Restaurant in Youngstown, OH. Enjoy favorites like Chicken Parmesan, Lasagna, Cavatelli, and more, plus a private meeting room. Call +1 330-757-4042 today!

Welcome to The Fireplace

Experience the finest dining

The Fireplace
The Fireplace
The Fireplace
The Fireplace

Nestled comfortably at 2075 E Western Reserve Rd in Youngstown, The Fireplace is your go-to American restaurant for a hearty meal that hits the spot. With a casual yet inviting atmosphere, this restaurant welcomes families, friends, and anyone in between. Whether it's a Friday dinner or a Tuesday lunch, the menu brims with flavors that keep patrons coming back for more.

From classic Chicken Francais to deliciously layered Lasagna, there's a dish to please every palate.

With friendly service and a cozy ambiance, it’s hard not to feel at home. A separate meeting room allows for special gatherings, making it an ideal spot for celebrations or casual get-togethers. Come on down to The Fireplace and enjoy a delicious meal that feels just right.

The Fireplace boasts a broad range of features that cater to diners seeking comfort and variety. Not only does it serve a rich menu of American comfort food, but it also showcases Italian specialties that make it a local gem. The extensive menu includes everything from savory entrees like Chicken & Rib Combos to delightful appetizers like Crispy Fried Shrimp.

The restaurant has a designated meeting room for private events, ensuring your gatherings enjoy a touch of intimacy while being surrounded by fantastic food.

Furthermore, the casual decor, punctuated by warm lighting and rustic touches, creates a sense of belonging. Peak times reveal just how popular this spot is, especially on Fridays, making it essential to plan ahead if you're aiming for those prime evening hours.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

2075 E Western Reserve Rd, Youngstown, OH 44514, United States

Phone

+1 330-757-4042

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

The Fireplace
The Fireplace
The Fireplace
The Fireplace

The Fireplace caters to a diverse clientele in Youngstown, blending the charm of American dining with a hint of Italian flair. The impressive menu not only represents classic American favorites but also highlights beloved Italian dishes, ensuring each meal resonates with warmth and flavor. Diners rave about Chicken Parmesan and homemade Cavatelli, proving that each dish is crafted with care and creativity.

Catering to various appetites, the restaurant offers a sizable children's menu along with scrumptious desserts like the Chocolate Volcano and Rootbeer Float.

There's a delightful spread of salads, appetizers, and entrees available, ensuring that every visit feels like a new adventure in flavor. Although lunch periods might not be as busy, dinner attracts lively crowds, particularly on Fridays, encouraging a vibrant atmosphere perfect for sharing meals with loved ones.

The Fireplace enjoys strong community ties and frequently hosts local events, making it more than just a dining spot; it’s a gathering place for friends and families.

As the local temperature drops, the restaurant's name reflects the warmth and comfort felt within its walls, offering a perfect refuge for those seeking a satisfying meal. The commitment to excellent service, wholesome food, and community engagement is evident in every detail.

The Fireplace

The Fireplace presents a welcoming exterior that invites diners to come inside. With its rustic wooden accents and warm lighting, the building radiates a charm that stands out along E Western Reserve Rd. Upon entering, guests find a cozy and family-oriented vibe that encourages everyone to feel right at home.

The outdoor seating offers a pleasant option for those who prefer to dine al fresco during warmer months, enhancing the inviting ambiance of the restaurant. Whether enjoying dinner after a long day or celebrating a special occasion, the atmosphere feels perfect for spending quality time together.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday4:30-8:30 PM
  • Wednesday4:30-8:30 PM
  • Thursday4:30-8:30 PM
  • Friday4:30-8:30 PM
  • Saturday4:30-8:30 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Rarely do I give all 5 stars. I came here many years ago and ordered a steak salad and the steak was so fatty that I basically threw it out so Friday the 26th of December decided to eat here again. Oddly enough after talking to our waitress kelsey I ordered it again. It was phenomenal. My kids got the fish dinners. Son liked the fish but not the Mac and cheese and daughter liked the sides but not the fish. What highlighted our visit was kelsey. One of the best waitresses I have ever encountered and I eat out constantly. Because of her service we will be back.

M
Michael S.

Food was amazing! So greatful we tried this restaurant for the first time the other night in Poland ohio. We're still fairly new to the area and wanted to try something different. We chose The Fireplace and were pleasantly surprised by the food and the prices. For under 60.00 I fed my family of 4 with an amazing meal. The burgers were juicy and fat, the fries were crisp but not burnt or over seasoned, and the chicken Absolutely delicious. The employees were very courteous and friendly. Thank you for the delightful service and meal. Will be going back very soon!

T
Tristan T.

What a gem. The food was so tasty and fresh and reasonably priced for what you receive. Friendly atmosphere and very clean and updated. I had the chicken francais. Great taste. If you're there, try the shrimp appetizer you'll love it.

R
Ralph F.

Briar hill pizza, greens, chicken parm, all delicious. Linguini and clam sauce was good. It took a little extra time to get our food but no big deal. Tables and booth seating with plenty of room.

B
Brenda B.

A great place to eat in Poland, Ohio and The Mahoning Valley. They have fantastic homemade bread. I have had their Fish, Lasagna and Pasta. All are fantastic. I recently tried their Pepper and Egg Sandwich, it is great as well. Great atmosphere and great service!

A
Alan C.

Super friendly and helpful staff. Very nice local establishment with a bar area and plenty of booths and tables to dine at. Food is classic old school with tremendous quality and flavor. Highly Recommended. A+++

J
Jay T.